At notoriety level 10, the pirate is asked to visit Elizabeth Swann, who promises to teach them how to use a new weapon. She, in turn, sends them to Will Turner to make them a set of special daggers.
| Name | Task | Reward |
| Visit Elizabeth Swann | Visit Elizabeth Swann in Governor's Mansion on Port Royal. | 500 Notoriety Points |
| Visit Will Turner | Visit Will Turner in the Old Warehouse on Port Royal. | 100 Notoriety Points |
| Sterling Silver Ingots | Recover 3 silver ingots from East India Trading Co Sentinel ships. | 100 Notoriety Points |
| Fine Steel Rods | Recover 3 steel rods from Navy Panther ships. | 100 Notoriety Points |
| Tongs | Recover tongs from 14 Undead Witchdoctors. | 100 Notoriety Points |
| Coal | Recover a bucket of coal from a barrel. | 100 Notoriety Points |
| Bones | Recover Bones from 14 Undead Brutes | 100 Notoriety Points |
| Visit Elizabeth Swann | Visit Elizabeth Swann. | 100 Notoriety Points |
| Recover Message | Recover a message from a East India Trading Co Corvette ship. | 100 Notoriety Points |
| Visit Will Turner | Visit Will Turner. | 100 Notoriety Points |
| Deliver Knives | Take the knives to Elizabeth Swann. | 500 Notoriety Points Use of Daggers and Throwing Knives. |
Note: Additional daggers or throwing knives can be purchased at any blacksmith or found in loot drops, but they can only be used after this quest.