At Doll level 15, this quest will unlock. After completing this quest the player will receive the Pirate Doll.
Game Note:
- This doll bears a strong resemblance to Captain Barbossa.
| Name | Task | Reward |
| Visit Tia Dalma | Visit Tia Dalma | 100 Notoriety Points |
| Visit Romany Bev | Visit Romany Bev | 100 Notoriety Points |
| Return to Tia Dalma | Visit Tia Dalma | 100 Notoriety Points |
| Masts | Recover 6 sunken ship masts from any Galleon or Frigate. | 100 Notoriety Points |
| Battle-Touched Earth | Defeat something hostile on islands around the Caribbean and take a sample of the ground you fought on. |
none |
| Recover a bottle of battle-touched earth from an enemy on Tortuga. | 100 Notoriety Points | |
| Recover a bottle of battle-touched earth from an enemy on Cuba. | 100 Notoriety Points | |
| Recover a bottle of battle-touched earth from an enemy on Tortuga. | 100 Notoriety Points | |
| Recover a bottle of battle-touched earth from an enemy on Driftwood Island. | 100 Notoriety Points | |
| Recover a bottle of battle-touched earth from an enemy on Kingshead. | 100 Notoriety Points | |
| Recover a bottle of battle-touched earth from an enemy on Isla Cangrejos. | 100 Notoriety Points | |
| Recover a bottle of battle-touched earth from an enemy on Rumrunner's Isle. | 100 Notoriety Points | |
| Recover a bottle of battle-touched earth from an enemy on Isla Perdida. | 100 Notoriety Points | |
| Recover a bottle of battle-touched earth from an enemy on Port Royal. | 100 Notoriety Points | |
| Recover a bottle of battle-touched earth from an enemy on Devil's Anvil. | 100 Notoriety Points | |
| Recover a bottle of battle-touched earth from an enemy on Padres Del Fuego. | 100 Notoriety Points | |
| Recover a bottle of battle-touched earth from an enemy on Isla Tormenta. | 100 Notoriety Points | |
| Recover a bottle of battle-touched earth from an enemy on Outcast Isle. | 100 Notoriety Points | |
| Recover a bottle of battle-touched earth from an enemy on Cutthroat Isle. | 100 Notoriety Points | |
| Bones | Recover 8 skeleton bones from Skeletons. | 100 Notoriety Points |
| The First Relic Piece | Recover a relic piece from an Undead Gypsy. | 100 Notoriety Points |
| Additional Relic Pieces | Recover 5 relic pieces from Undead Grenadiers. | 100 Notoriety Points |
| Acquire components for destruction spell | none | |
| Recover 6 crab claws from Sand Crabs. | 100 Notoriety Points | |
| Recover 6 scorpion venom from Dread Scorpions. | 100 Notoriety Points | |
| Recover 6 stingers from Terror Wasps. | 100 Notoriety Points | |
| Recover 6 bottles of battle-touched water from Skeleton ships. | 100 Notoriety Points | |
| Recover 6 alligator teeth from Big Alligator. | 100 Notoriety Points | |
| Recover 6 bat claws from Vampire Bats. | 100 Notoriety Points | |
| Return the Components | Visit Tia Dalma. | 100 Notoriety Points Pirate Doll  |