User blog comment:Obsidion Darkhart/Guide guidelines/@comment-3143993-20110605034042

The three proposed guidelines are a good start. I would also suggest that the guide topics be kept to a limited number of general topics. I don't want to see "Joe McKidd's Guide to Leveling Cursed Broadswords," for example. (Or has such a guide already been made?)

I also think that the names of individual pirates should not be allowed in the titles, which may serve to reduce the ego-boosting aspects of creating guides. To avoid having lots of self-aggrandizing images flood the guides, I would suggest limiting images to those without personal data whenever possible.

Much of the content of guides has already been included as game notes on the specific topic pages. Should the game notes be left as is, even when duplicated in the guides? If we limit the guides to one per topic then having certain information in game notes seems almost superfluous.